Smith, points of comparison and contrast could include classroom management, teaching styles and extracurricular involvement. Without it, students with little motivation may not write the essay.
This helps peers recognize that the essay is incomplete. For example: "The most notable difference between Mr. Tell students to read their essay aloud or to have someone else read it to them to catch any errors. Staple a rubric to each essay and have students evaluate them.
They should continue the cycle of editing and revising until they are satisfied with the quality of their essay. They have been used in regular high school classes where reading levels ranged from fourth to twelfth grade. A lot of times this gets pushed to the back burner, and we practice the skill of comparing and contrasting with things that are less frustrating and take less time — like the overused Venn Diagram.
Melissa Kelly has a master's degree in secondary education and over eight years of experience in the classroom. To make a Venn diagram, draw two overlapping circles -- one for each of the two subjects.
Another would be a store manager writing to a buyer about two products. Consider giving 25 points each for evaluating three essays and another 25 points for quiet participation.
All of my 3rd grade students — even my more advanced and gifted students — benefited from additional scaffolding when writing any essay, but especially a compare and contrast essay.
Comparing and contrasting different items helps people to think more critically about the subject, whether it's an everyday decision or an academic exercise.